Topic: The Hobbit

Bilbo Baggins is presented as a superior model for modern life compared to the traditional "Luke Skywalker" hero. Rather than defeating a primary villain, Bilbo is swept up by history and simply does his best in small, moment-to-moment situations. This "Hobbit" approach emphasizes that even the smallest individuals can change the course of history through their immediate choices.

Using Bilbo Baggins as a model for living in a chaotic world, White contrasts the "Hero's Journey" of Luke Skywalker with Bilbo's more realistic experience of being swept up by history. He highlights the "pity of Bilbo"—the decision not to kill Gollum—as a small act that ultimately determined the fate of Middle Earth. This serves as a metaphor for how individuals can impact history through small, nonlinear actions and maintaining personal integrity within their own "Hobbit holes" rather than trying to defeat a singular "Sauron."

DeLucia warns against amateur exploration of cavern worlds, citing folklore and literature like The Hobbit that describe dangerous inhabitants such as orcs and goblins. He recounts seeing a drawing of an elf with a sinister, demonic face, challenging the romanticized view of these beings as beautiful enchantresses.